The commander ban list, as voted by you.

Over the last few day's we've gotten over 500 replies on what you think the ban list should look like. I separated it into both the casual crowd and competitive minded players and here are the results.

There were a good amount of votes to unban or ban everything and I think that will show a lot in the overall results. Troll or not the list doesn't look unlikely for people's thoughts so I went with it.

And yes I released I spelled some names wrong but if I changed them it would reset the votes so fuck it.

CASUAL (261 VOTES)

Keep banned forever according to you guys

Black lotus 236 votes (90.4%)

Time vault 232 votes (88.9%)

Time walk 226 votes (86.6%)

Mox Jet/Mox Sapphire 220 votes (84.3%)

If we unbanned everything with 50 percent or less these guys would be free today

Biorhythm (42.1%)

Braids, Cabal Minion (38.3%)

Coalition Victory (30.7%)

Gifts Ungiven (29.9%)

Painter's Servant (41.8%)

Primeval Titan (47.5%)

Prophet of Kruphix (47.9%)

Recurring Nightmare (43.7%)

Rofellos, Llanowar emissary (45.2%)

Sylvan Primordial (48.3%)

Some notes on what I've noticed according to these votes

- Erayo is the only card that should stay banned that is banned as commander.

- Mox Jet and Sapphire and more offensive than the other three. Interesting because the two that scored lowest are arguably the worst colors in commander

- A majority of the cards people want unbanned were the recent bannings of Prophet, Prime Time, and Sylvan

COMPETITIVE: (233 VOTES)

Keep banned forever according to you guys

Black lotus 204 votes (87.6%)

Time Walk/Mox Emerald/Mox Jet 193 votes (82.8%)

Mox Ruby/Mox Pearl/Mox Sapphire 192 votes (82.4%)

Time vault 191 votes (82%)

Ancestral Recall 184 votes (79%)

If we unbanned everything with 50 percent or less these guys would be free today

Biorhythm (23.6%)

Braids, Cabal Minion (16.3%)

Coalition Victory (18.9%)

Emrakul, the Aeons torn (44.2%)

Erayo, Soratami Ascendant (43.8%)

Gifts ungiven (25.8%)

Limited Resources (48.9%)

Painters Servant (24%)

Panoptic Mirror (36.1%)

Primeval Titan (26.2%)

Prophet of Kruphix (21.5%)

Recurring Nightmare (34.3%)

Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary (30.5%)

Sundering titan (29.6%)

Sway of the stars (34.8%)

Sylvan Primordial (28.3%)

Trade Secrets (45.1%)

Upheaval (42.1%)

Worldfire (33%)

As expected every card that you guys want unbanned in casual is on here as well.

In some cases (Worldfire and Sundering Titan) it seems like these cards are more ok than cards deemed ok on the casual list

The Moxes seemed odd in this case where Jet and Emerald got more votes than Sapphire some how. I think that's just imperfect results showing itself.

Anyway, thanks for all your time in filling out my survey. I got a lot of interesting information from you.

Until next time.

DoomBlade, Signing out


If you want to support the blog please visit my Patreon for more. Every little bit helps a ton and allows me to make more content for you guys in the future https://www.patreon.com/diestodoomblade


FREE BRAIDS 2017!